Blair Witch Gives Fan Service To Non-Fans

Director: Adam Wingard Starring: Callie Hernandez, James Allen McCune Running Time: 89 minutes

In 1999, The Blair Witch Project was released amidst a massive wave of hype, propelled by early attempts at viral marketing and a ‘based on a true story’ flimflam that caught viewers offguard. With more story around the film than in it and a loose structure much closer to actual found footage than the genre staple tends to be today, it really was a project, a different kind of horror than audiences had seen before. However, audiences often don’t want different and the backlash was swift and the rushed and disastrous sequel Book of Shadows did little to help. Nearly two decades later, new sequel Blair Witch has flown in deliberately under the radar, filmed under the misdirect title The WoodsBlair Witch frequently feels like the kind of film viewers thought the original was offering, which should satisfy some but those who were happy with what they got first time around might leave disappointed.

Blair Witch sees paramedic Jason Donaghue motivated by a grainy internet video to journey into the spooky Black Hills woods, hoping to find some trace of his long lost sister Heather (she of the snotty confession in the first film). He’s accompanied by friends who, in addition to looking and acting like they were just off to the side of the screen on One Tree Hill for years, also include film students who want to document the search on their flashy tech, including ear cameras, web cams and a drone. Joined by some local weirdos who seem way too into the old legends of the Blair Witch, they set off camping and everything goes fine and Jason finds his sister and no witches get involved. Or not.

Though the plots of the two films are essentially the same, Blair Witch takes a different approach to scares than its predecessor. What was interesting (if undeniably alienating) about The Blair Witch Project was how it prioritised more basic fears than horror movies are usually interested in; fear of getting lost, of having no control, of being suddenly alone. Its forest setting tapped into something primal in audiences, aided by a low budget and improvised performances that helped it feel much closer to actual found footage than most of the films in that genre that have come in the years since. Blair Witch too rarely pushes those same buttons, typically getting scares from the more usual jump scares and gore.

Frequently the film feels like it received notes from the studio to avoid the elements that caused backlash to its predecessor. “It’s boring” – add jump scares and a body count. “The characters are stupid jerks” – the characters are beautiful, flat archetypes. “How dare they act like it was real” – don’t even try to come across as real. More characters means more cameras which means more cuts, keeping the audience one safer step away from the reality of the film. Now that its a franchise and small details like piles of rocks, twig dolls and time loss have become established rules it may not be possible to put the cat back into the bag as far as atmosphere goes, but too often it’s just like watching Paranormal Activity: Camping Edition.

The more conventional approach is disappointing considering the talent involved behind the camera. Director and writer Adam Wingard and Simon Barrett are responsible for two of the more fun and fresh genre films of recent years in You’re Next and The Guest, but its only towards the end that they really sink their teeth into the material. The cabin-set climax ramps up the scares considerably, making the jump scares actually effective and assaulting the senses unrelentingly. Its a great sequence but its a long slog through the woods to get there.  It may be just enough for newcomers and detractors from 1999 to find Blair Witch worthwhile viewing, but in a strong year for horror too often it struggles to notably distinguish itself from its competition or its source.

Luke Dunne
About me

Luke is a writer, film addict and Dublin native who loves how much there is for film fans in his home county. A former writer for FilmFixx and the Freakin' Awesome Network, he founded Film In Dublin to pursue his dual dreams of writing about film and never sleeping ever again.


Freaky review
Body swaps, blood and guts in Freaky
July 06, 2021
Rogue Aurora
Movie Memories: Glamour ghoul Rogue Aurora on drag, horror and gremlins
June 24, 2021
Irish Comedy at VMDIFF21 Deadly Cuts Boys From County Hell
Review Round-Up: Irish Comedy at VMDIFF21
March 25, 2021
Bleeding Hearts IFI Horrorthon
Bleeding Hearts this Valentine’s Day thanks to IFI’s My Bloody Horrorthon
February 08, 2021
His House 2020
Ghosts haunt the home, the heart and the mind in His House
October 31, 2020
Raw Horror
10 Lesser Known Horror Films For Your Lockdown Trick or Treat Basket
October 30, 2020
IFI Horrorthon 2020
The IFI Horrorthon 2020 brings new and old chills and spills from around the world
October 06, 2020
The Babysitter Killer Queen
The Babysitter: Killer Queen isn’t quite guaranteed to blow your mind
September 12, 2020
John Boyega - Attack the Block
The Breakout Role Podcast – John Boyega
August 28, 2020


Reply September 19, 2016

Really interesting write up, I might go see this. I saw the original film when first released and actually found it terrifying, although watched it again recently and it didn't even come close to that. I guess that's because the original film was more about what you don't actually see and what you imagine is happening therefore doesn't have the same impact on a second viewing. It will be interesting to see if the film matches up to my imagination all those years ago!!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.